QUR’ANIC REVELATIONS – A CRITICAL STUDY UNDER THE
SEARCHLIGHT OF TRUTH AND LOGIC
By, Sujit Das
An excerpt from an extensive and comprehensive debate (Ghamidi et.
al, 2007.
p.
52) between
Javed Ahmad Ghamidi, Khalid Zaheer vs.
Ali Sina, is as follows;...
More
QUR’ANIC REVELATIONS – A CRITICAL STUDY UNDER THE
SEARCHLIGHT OF TRUTH AND LOGIC
By, Sujit Das
An excerpt from an extensive and comprehensive debate (Ghamidi et.
al, 2007.
p.
52) between
Javed Ahmad Ghamidi, Khalid Zaheer vs.
Ali Sina, is as follows;
*****
Ghamidi / Zaheer: “We have been informed in the Qur’an that the message of
God Almighty comes to the messengers through angels”.
Ali Sina: “By whom? By the Qur’an itself? Isn’t this circular reasoning? How do
you know this is true? If the Qur’an is a lie, then this claim is also a lie.
We ask,
what is the proof that Muhammad is a true messenger? You answer, it is written in
the Qur’an.
” We ask, how can we know that the Qur’an is the word of God? You
say, because Muhammad said so.
This is a logical fallacy, not proof”.
*****
A Hadith (Volume 1, Number 3) from Sahih Bukhari recorded Muhammad’s first experience with
the Gabriel.
Muhammad used to go in seclusion in the cave of Hira and worship continuously for
many days.
Once
Less